Adrian Berry  
Science author and columnist   
Home | About Adrian | Subjects | Contact Me | Reviews | Links 
 

Beeline to the Moon?

With the full speed of a snail, Nasa is preparing itself to send astronauts to the Moon and Mars. This summer it has started to carry out experiments that ought to have been performed years ago.

The first of these is an attempt to develop a technique for extracting air from lunar rocks and soil. This will be essential if there are to be manned bases on the Moon. People wishing to stay there for an indefinite time cannot rely on air tanks that they brought up with them from Earth, as the Apollo astronauts did.

The Moon has no atmosphere - or virtually none. Yet much of the material to be found on its surface is made of oxides, compounds of oxygen with iron, aluminium, titanium and silicon. Lunar explorers in science fiction stories routinely extract oxygen from these compounds, but no one, as far as I know, has yet done it in real life.

Now Nasa, in collaboration with the state-owned Florida Space Research Institute, is offering a prize of $250,000 (surely a pitifully small reward) to the first team than can extract five kilograms of oxygen from simulated lunar soil by June 2008.

And at long last, Nasa has decided to carry out experiments in artificial gravity. That is to say spinning a manned spacecraft, or part of it, to produce centrifugal force that would give Mars-bound astronauts some form of gravity so that they don't arrive on the Red Planet as basket cases after months of weightlessness.

Nasa's plan to build Crew Exploration Vehicles that will replace the space shuttles is not having a good press. According to space historian Robert Zimmerman, quoted in the Wall Street Journal on May 25, 2005, winning contractors will have to submit 129 reports and ``tangle with a snarl of red tape.''

The journal added: "Minority hiring, small business support and outreach in public education have nothing to do with cutting edge research, but they found their way into the application process. Winners will also be expected to maintain a company programme for drug and alcohol abuse."' The result, Mr Zimmerman says, is to "discourage some of the more innovative and smaller new aerospace companies."'

Meanwhile in the private sector there is a very different atmosphere. Peter Diamandis, chairman and chief executive of the X-Prize Foundation that last year awarded Bert Rutan's company a $10 million prize for being the first to fly a manned craft, SpaceShip One, to a sub-orbital 300,000 feet, said in a recent speech that within three years of a private manned spacecraft achieving orbital flight, "you'll have teams of people stockpiling fuel in orbit and making a beeline for the Moon."'

Whether or not this happens as quickly as he predicts, it is completely logical. In the long term, space is no place for governments. Nasa is very good at science - perhaps the only thing it does really well - but when it comes to exploitation, tourism, mining and making profits, these are tasks for the private sector.

And as for offering rewards, as we have seen in the above examples, the latter is 40 times more generous than the former.

Home | About Adrian | Subjects | Contact Me | Reviews | Links