Adrian Berry  
Science author and columnist   
Home | About Adrian | Subjects | Contact Me | Reviews | Links 
 

Universe in Chaos

Questions that No One Can Answer

WHEN Mars approached us more closely in the summer of 2003 than it had done for tens of thousands of years, it revealed an extraordinary truth about the nature of the universe.

This truth lay in a mysterious failure to agree upon how many tens of millennia had elapsed since the same previous close approach of the Red Planet.

It was first announced that this number should be 60,000 years. But further calculations suggested 70,000 years. Then 100,000, then 50,000.

 

In fact nobody knows, and there is no way to find out. No software program can tell us, since the necessary data does not exist. Far from being the precise clockwork construction that Isaac Newton and his followers long supposed it to be, the solar system is wholly chaotic. Long-term forecasts about the future orbits of the planets are wild guesses - the longer the term the wilder the guess - since Newton's laws of motion are mere approximations.

This represents a vast change in attitude. These laws used to be considered almost divine for their powers of accuracy. The mathematician Pierre Laplace speculated two centuries ago about an omniscient being

``...which knew at a given instant all of the forces by which nature is animated, and the relative positions of all the objects, and which, if it were sufficiently powerful to analyse all this information, would include in one formula [my italics] the movements of the most massive objects in the universe and those of the lightest atom. Nothing would be uncertain to it. The future, as the past, would be present to its eyes.''

But no such omniscient being can exist. The positions of objects change constantly as if manipulated by an unseen power. For in addition to being influenced by the Sun, the planets are also influenced by each other. And slightly but inexorably, they feel the tug of moons, asteroids, comets and passing stars. Over extremely long periods, this makes their motions utterly unpredictable.

Because the Moon is a quarter of a million miles away, we imagine that it was always at that distance. But it is believed to have formed only 20,000 miles away, and to have been migrating outwards ever since.

Neptune is thought to have moved 30 per cent further away from us since its formation - over 700 million miles! - and it may be only a matter of time before it collides with Pluto. The other giant planets have also moved by significant amounts. Our solar system probably bears little resemblance to what it looked like three billion years ago. It is even possible that a planet could be ejected entirely from the Sun's neighbourhood!

I do not mean to imply that any such event is likely to happen tomorrow morning. Many people will remember the ridiculous 1950 book Worlds in Collision by Immanuel Velikovsky, who theorised that during Biblical times a comet from Jupiter's orbit came close to crashing into Earth before becoming the planet Venus!

But over eons of time truly bizarre events may be expected. A star cluster was recently discovered far out in intergalactic space. Who knows what intricate combinations of causes threw it so far from the galaxy where it must have formed.

Home | About Adrian | Subjects | Contact Me | Reviews | Links