Adrian Berry  
Science author and columnist   
Home | About Adrian | Subjects | Contact Me | Reviews | Links 
 

Rising Meteors!

Sloppy Language

WHEN an official was unexpectedly promoted, one newspaper commented with excitement on his ``meteoric rise". The ignorance of this remark infuriated me, since meteors do not rise: they fall. There is a deplorable tendency among people who know nothing about science to use scientific terms and get them wrong.

One of the worst examples (although it has nothing to do with astronomy) is the pejorative use of the word ``dinosaur". Any group of people seen as reactionary, obstinate, or vaguely stuffy are routinely labelled ``dinosaurs". This is despite the fact that the dinosaurs, the most successful group of species that ever lived, lasted 160 million years, more than 2,000 times longer that the whole history of modern humans!

Another frequently misused term is ``light-year". People wrongly use it to denote time instead of distance, misled perhaps, because it contains the word ``year". Tony Blair did this in a recent speech. But he was in good company. In the first Star Wars movie, Han Solo, played by Harrison Ford, says: "I can get to [such-and-such a world] in 12 parsecs. ``This is like saying: "I can get to Birmingham in 100 miles."

``Galaxy" is often misused, even when we are not talking about chocolate bars or military aircraft. A news agency reported last year that three planets had been found ``in another galaxy, 44 light years away". Ominous news indeed, if another galaxy had sneaked up so close! The correct term of course was ``solar system".

People say the strangest things about black holes. A meteorologist, explaining magnetic storms which disrupt electricity supplies, was quoted as blaming ``exploding black holes on the surface of the Sun". Surely he meant sunspots?

There is a popular but lunatic theory that the Sun, for some reason or other, will turn into a black hole and swallow up the Earth. This cannot happen. Even if, by some extraordinary procedure, it became a black hole, its gravity, coming from a point source, would affect Earth exactly as it does today. Admittedly our days would become somewhat dark and cold, but that is another story.

There exists indeed a respectable theory that one day Earth will be struck by a ``black apocalypse". Statistically, this could happen about once every 100 billion years. A black hole of several solar masses could rush into the Solar System and tear our planet to wisps of debris. Such a catastrophe could be occurring even now in the star system Cygnus X-1.

Statisticians, incidentally, can talk as much nonsense as anyone, usually because they misunderstand their data. Mark Twain once satirised them nicely: ``In the space of 176 years the Mississippi river has shortened itself by 242 miles. [Therefore] in the old Silurian system the Mississippi was upwards of 1.3 million miles long. Seven hundred and forty two years from now, the Mississippi will be only one and three quarter miles long. There is something fascinating about science. One gets such wholesale returns of conjecture out of such a trifling investment of fact.''

Home | About Adrian | Subjects | Contact Me | Reviews | Links